Pro’s & Con’s

An asphalt roof, typically made from asphalt shingles, is one of the most common roofing choices for homes. Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons:

Pros ✅

1. Affordability – Asphalt shingles are one of the most cost-effective roofing materials compared to metal, tile, or slate.
2. Variety of Styles & Colors – They come in different colors, textures, and designs to match various home aesthetics.
3. Easy Installation & Repairs – Relatively simple to install and replace, which can reduce labor costs.
4. Decent Durability – With proper installation and maintenance, they can last 15-30 years, depending on the quality.
5. Lightweight – Unlike heavier materials like tile or slate, asphalt doesn’t require additional structural support.
6. Good Fire Resistance – Most asphalt shingles are Class A fire-rated when installed with appropriate underlayment.
7. Energy Efficiency Options – Reflective shingles are available to help reduce heat absorption and lower cooling costs.

Cons ❌

1. Shorter Lifespan – Compared to metal, tile, or slate, asphalt shingles don’t last as long (metal can last 50+ years).
2. Weather Vulnerability – Can be prone to damage from high winds, hail, and extreme temperature fluctuations.
3. Moss & Algae Growth – In humid climates, algae and moss can grow, leading to stains and deterioration.
4. Not the Most Eco-Friendly – While some asphalt shingles are recyclable, most end up in landfills.
5. Can Absorb Heat – Standard asphalt shingles retain heat, which can increase cooling costs in hot climates.
6. Granule Loss Over Time – Shingles lose granules due to weather and aging, reducing their protective abilities.

A standing seam metal roof is a high-quality roofing option that features raised seams running vertically along the panels. It’s a popular choice for both residential and commercial buildings due to its durability and modern appearance.

Pros ✅

1. Longevity – Can last 40–70 years, much longer than asphalt shingles (which last 15–30 years).
2. Durability – Resistant to cracking, shrinking, and eroding; holds up well against high winds, hail, and heavy rain.
3. Energy Efficiency – Reflects sunlight, reducing cooling costs in hot climates. Some coatings improve efficiency even further.
4. Low Maintenance – Requires minimal upkeep compared to asphalt and wood shingles.
5. Eco-Friendly – Often made from recycled materials and fully recyclable at the end of its lifespan.
6. Fire Resistance – Metal roofs are Class A fire-rated, offering excellent fire protection.
7. Snow & Ice Shedding – Smooth surface helps snow and ice slide off easily, preventing buildup and leaks.
8. Modern Aesthetic – Sleek and contemporary look that works well for modern and farmhouse-style homes.

Cons ❌

1. Higher Initial Cost – More expensive upfront than asphalt shingles, both in material and installation costs.
2. Difficult & Costly Repairs – Replacing a damaged panel is more challenging than replacing individual shingles.
3. Noise Factor – Can be noisier in heavy rain or hail unless proper insulation or underlayment is used.
4. Expansion & Contraction – Metal expands and contracts with temperature changes, which can loosen fasteners over time if not installed correctly.
5. Oil Canning – Some panels may develop visible waviness, which is a cosmetic issue but not a structural concern.
6. Limited DIY Options – Requires specialized installation, meaning fewer contractors and higher labor costs.

BOTTOM LINE

A standing seam metal roof is an excellent investment if you prioritize durability, energy efficiency, and longevity. However, it comes with a higher upfront cost. If you plan to stay in your home long-term, it can be worth it compared to the frequent replacements needed for asphalt shingles.

An AG (Agricultural) metal roof, also known as corrugated metal roofing, is a popular choice for barns, sheds, and even homes due to its affordability and durability. Here’s a breakdown of its advantages and disadvantages:

Pros ✅

1. Affordability – Less expensive than standing seam metal roofs and often cheaper than high-end asphalt shingles.
2. Durability – Resistant to harsh weather, including wind, rain, and snow. Can last 30–50 years with proper maintenance.
3. Easy Installation – Simpler to install compared to standing seam metal, making labor costs lower.
4. Lightweight – Puts less stress on the structure compared to heavier roofing materials like tile or slate.
5. Good Weather Resistance – Coated versions (Galvalume or painted finishes) resist rust and corrosion.
6. Low Maintenance – Requires minimal upkeep, just periodic inspections for rust, fasteners, and sealant integrity.
7. Good Water Shedding – The ridged design helps quickly channel water away, reducing leaks.
8. Eco-Friendly – Made from recycled materials and fully recyclable.

Cons ❌

1. Exposed Fasteners – Screws go through the panels, making them prone to leaks over time as fasteners loosen.
2. Shorter Lifespan than Standing Seam – While durable, AG metal doesn’t last as long as standing seam due to potential fastener and seal failure.
3. Less Aesthetic Appeal – Often looks more industrial or agricultural, which may not suit all residential home styles.
4. Prone to Rust – If not properly coated or maintained, rust can develop, especially in coastal or humid environments.
5. Noise Issues – Can be noisy in heavy rain or hail unless additional insulation is installed.
6. Expansion & Contraction – Like all metal roofs, AG panels expand and contract with temperature changes, which can loosen screws over time.
7. More Maintenance Over Time – Fasteners and seals may need checking and replacement to prevent leaks.

BOTTOM LINE

AG metal roofing is an excellent budget-friendly choice, especially for barns, sheds, and homes where aesthetics aren’t the top priority. However, if you want a longer-lasting, more watertight metal roof for a house, standing seam is the better investment.